Key takeaways
- Broken link building means finding links on other sites that point to dead pages and offering a working replacement.
- The best targets are dead resources in the client's niche that many relevant sites still link to.
- The replacement page has to be genuinely useful on its own, not a thin copy of the old one.
- It stays white hat only while nothing is paid or traded for the link.
Broken link building is one of the few outreach tactics where the email starts with a favor: you tell an editor their page has a dead link and offer a working alternative. We use it inside white label SEO programs for clients in niches with long-lived resource pages, such as health, home services, education and B2B. This guide covers how it works, where it fits in a link plan and where the limits are. For the wider rules on client sites, see our safe link building guide.
How does broken link building work?
You find a page in the client's niche that has disappeared, list the sites that still link to it, and check what the old page offered. Then you publish a better resource on the client site and email each linking site, pointing out the dead link and suggesting the new page as a replacement for their readers.
The dead page usually returns a 404 or 410. Google's guide to HTTP status codes explains that these URLs drop out of the index, but the links pointing at them stay on other sites until an editor removes or replaces them. That window is the opportunity.
How do you find broken links on other websites?
Start from topics, not tools. Search for resource pages and guides in the client niche, crawl them for outbound links that return errors, and note dead pages that several sites linked to. A backlink tool can also list a competitor's or publisher's broken pages along with the sites that still link to each one.
- Search for resource and links pages in the niche, for example the topic plus "resources" or "useful links".
- Crawl those pages and filter outbound links that return 404, 410 or DNS errors.
- Check the dead URL in the Wayback Machine to see what it covered.
- Pull the sites that still link to the dead URL from your backlink tool.
- Keep only targets where the linking sites are real, relevant and still maintained.
The client's own site also has broken pages with links. Those are a reclamation job, not outreach: the Search Console Links report shows the most linked pages, and any that now return an error should get a redirect first.
How do you build a replacement that deserves the link?
Study what the dead page offered and why people linked to it, then build something more current and more useful: updated data with sources, clearer steps, better examples. It must fit the client's expertise. A page that only rewrites the old one gives editors no reason to switch and adds little value to the client site.
Google's guidance on helpful, people-first content is the right test: would this page exist if no link were at stake? If the answer is no, choose a different target. Our content writing team drafts the replacement, and a specialist checks it against the old page before any email goes out.
| Old resource | Weak replacement | Strong replacement |
|---|---|---|
| Outdated cost guide | Same guide with a new date | Current guide with sourced ranges and what changes the price |
| Closed supplier directory | Short list of links | Maintained list with criteria and notes on each option |
| Retired calculator or tool | Page describing the tool | Working tool or worksheet the reader can use |
| Old checklist | Copy of the checklist | Checklist plus examples and the reason for each step |
What does good broken link outreach look like?
A short, personal email to the person who maintains the page. Name the page, quote the dead link and where it sits, and offer the replacement in one sentence with a reason it helps their readers. Do not demand the link, do not send a template blast, and send only one follow-up.
Prioritize the list before writing. Sites that are clearly maintained (recent updates, working contact details, other live links) are worth an email; abandoned pages rarely reply. Group targets by the dead resource so one replacement page serves the whole batch, and record for each site the page URL, the dead link, the contact and the date sent. That sheet is what goes into the client report, along with each live link won and the replacement page it points to.
Lead with the broken link, not the client. Many editors fix the dead link and never use your page; that is fine and still builds goodwill. Our white label link building team writes each email by hand and logs every reply in the client sheet.
Is broken link building white hat?
Yes, as long as the editor chooses to link because the page is useful. It crosses the line when you pay for the replacement, offer a link swap, send free products in exchange, or buy expired domains to redirect their links. Google's spam policies list those exchanges as link spam, and they put the client at risk.
Google's spam policies name buying or selling links, exchanging goods or services for links and excessive link exchanges as link spam. If an editor asks for a fee, walk away or ask them to mark the link as sponsored, as Google explains in its guide to qualifying outbound links. Expect a modest reply rate and plan broken link building as one tactic in a mix; our guide to types of backlinks shows where it fits.
Real gaps only
Targets where several relevant sites still link to a dead page.
Better replacement
A page that would be worth publishing even without the links.
Nothing traded
No payments, swaps or gifts in exchange for a link.
Want broken link building delivered under your agency brand? book a 30-minute call.
Frequently asked questions
How long does a broken link building campaign take?
Plan for several weeks: research and the replacement page come first, then outreach and follow-ups. Track each contact, the date and the reply in a simple sheet so follow-ups stay polite and nothing is sent twice. Links usually arrive gradually over the following weeks as site owners update their pages.
Can we suggest a client page that already exists?
Yes, if it truly covers what the dead page offered. Often that is the fastest win. Check that the client page matches the topic and is as useful as the broken resource, then suggest it as a replacement in a short, helpful email that also points out the dead link.
Should we buy the expired domain of the dead resource?
No. Buying expired domains to redirect their links for ranking is the kind of manipulation Google's policies target. Earn links by offering a useful replacement page instead. It takes longer, but the links come from real editorial decisions and carry no risk of a manual action for the client.
Does broken link building work for local businesses?
Sometimes, through local resource pages, chambers and community sites, but the pool of targets is smaller. Look for broken links on local business associations, event listings, city guides and supplier pages. Even a few relevant local links can support rankings in the map pack and organic results.
Is it worth emailing if only one site links to the dead page?
Usually not as a campaign. Batch single targets with other outreach to the same site instead. Focus the campaign on pages with several linking sites, where one replacement page can win multiple links. Single targets can still be worth a short note when you are already in contact with the site owner.
Want these agency guides first? Choose White Label SEO LATAM as a preferred source on Google, and my articles are more likely to show up for you in Top Stories.
Follow on GoogleAdd as a preferred sourceSources
- Google Search Central, How HTTP status codes and network errors affect Google Search
- Search Console Help, Links report
- Google Search Central, Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content
- Google Search Central, Spam policies for Google web search
- Google Search Central, Qualify your outbound links to Google