Keyword difficulty: a useful filter, not a forecast.

Keyword difficulty is the number clients see first in a keyword report, and the one they misread most. A score of 70 does not mean a 70% chance of failure, and a score of 10 does not mean the client will rank next month. It is a tool's estimate, built from link data, and it means different things in different tools.

Key takeaways

  • Keyword difficulty (KD) is a 0 to 100 estimate of how hard it is to reach the top 10 for a keyword.
  • Semrush and Ahrefs both lean on the links pointing to the pages that already rank, but each calculates it differently.
  • KD ignores the client's own site, so a score of 40 can be easy for one client and out of reach for another.
  • Use KD as a first filter, then check the actual results page and the client's Search Console data.

Keyword difficulty is a metric every agency uses and few explain well to clients. In more than five years of SEO work, including SEO for 18 US online stores with more than 3 million products and technical SEO for over 600 car dealership sites, we have learned to treat KD as a sorting column, never as the answer. This guide explains what the score measures in the two most common tools, why scores disagree and how to use KD when choosing keywords for a client, as part of the research we deliver through white label SEO. Once keywords are chosen, assigning them to pages is the job of the keyword mapping template.

What is keyword difficulty?

Keyword difficulty is a score, usually from 0 to 100, that estimates how hard it would be to rank in the top 10 organic results for a keyword. Each SEO tool calculates its own version, mostly from the backlinks and authority of the pages already ranking. Higher scores mean stronger competition, not a fixed probability of success.

The important word is estimate. KD is a model of the current results page, built from a tool's own crawl, and it changes as that page changes. It does not know the client's content quality, brand demand or how well a page matches intent.

How is keyword difficulty calculated?

In Semrush, KD combines the median referring domains, the median dofollow to nofollow ratio and the median Authority Score of the ranking pages, plus features of the results page. In Ahrefs, KD is based on how many websites link to the top 10 ranking pages and does not account for on-page factors.

Semrush documents its method in the Keyword Difficulty score article and groups the percentage into labeled ranges. Ahrefs explains in its help center article What does KD stand for that KD is based on referring domains to top-ranking pages, that grey scores are cached when the results page has not been updated in 20 days or more, and that KD should not be the only basis for SEO decisions.

Semrush KD %Semrush labelWhat it usually means for an agency
0-14Very easyContent and on-page work may be enough
15-29EasyGood targets for newer or smaller client sites
30-49PossibleNeeds strong content and some authority
50-69DifficultNeeds links and a site with topical depth
70-84HardA long-term target, not a first-quarter goal
85-100Very hardUsually dominated by large, established sites

The ranges and labels are from Semrush; the right-hand column is our own reading, not a rule from the tool.

Why do keyword difficulty scores differ between tools?

Because each tool uses its own link index, its own formula and its own snapshot of the results page. Ahrefs says the tools all use the same 0 to 100 scale but calculate it differently. The same keyword can be 25 in one tool and 45 in another, and neither number is wrong by its own definition.

That point comes from the Ahrefs guide to estimating your chances to rank, which also explains that its KD pulls the top 10 ranking pages and counts the websites linking to each. Two practical rules follow. Pick one tool per client and stay with it, so scores in different reports are comparable. And never put KD from two tools side by side in a client deck without saying which is which.

How should agencies use keyword difficulty when choosing client keywords?

Use KD as a first filter, then judge the keyword against the client's own site. Compare the client's referring domains and authority with the pages that rank, check intent and the results page by hand, and look at Search Console for queries where the client already has impressions. Realistic targets usually sit where all three agree.

  • Sort the keyword list by KD inside the tool you use for this client.
  • Open the live results page for every shortlisted keyword: who ranks, what kind of page, what intent.
  • Compare the client's referring domains with the median of the top 10, not with the top result alone.
  • Check Search Console for queries where the client already ranks around positions 8 to 30.
  • Mark each keyword as quick win, build-up or long-term, and agree that split with the client.
  • Map the final list to pages so two pages never target the same term.

The Search Console step is often the most useful. The Performance report shows queries where Google already associates the client with a topic; those are often easier than any KD number suggests. For a deeper look at who owns the results page, see our guide to SEO competitor analysis.

What is personal keyword difficulty?

Personal keyword difficulty is a Semrush score that estimates how hard a keyword is for one specific domain, instead of for an average site. It considers how closely the domain's topic matches the keyword, the competition in that topic and the metrics of the client's domain against the domains already ranking. It is closer to the question clients ask.

Semrush explains in How is Personal Keyword Difficulty calculated that standard KD does not consider which domain you are researching for. For agencies, a domain-specific score is a better conversation starter, but it is still a model. Treat it the same way: a filter that earns a closer look, not a promise.

How do you explain keyword difficulty to a client?

Say that KD is a tool's estimate of how strong the current top 10 is, mostly measured by links, on a 0 to 100 scale. Explain that it does not include the client's own site, content or brand, and that you combine it with the results page and their data. Never translate KD into a ranking promise or a date.

We put one line under every keyword table: "Difficulty scores are estimates from one tool and do not predict rankings." It prevents the meeting where a client asks why a keyword marked easy has not reached page one. Our guide on SEO guarantees for agencies covers how to phrase expectations in proposals. If you need keyword research with realistic difficulty notes under your brand, our white label keyword research team delivers it. Or book a 30-minute call.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good keyword difficulty score for a new website?

Low scores in your tool, then a manual check of the results page. New sites usually start with long-tail terms. Look at who ranks today: forums, small sites and thin pages are good signs. They show that strong, focused content can win there within a few months.

Is a low KD keyword always worth targeting?

No. It still needs search demand, the right intent and a clear fit with what the client sells. A harder keyword with strong buyer intent can be worth more than several easy terms with no business value. Check the results page and the client's goals before choosing which keywords to target first.

Does keyword difficulty include search volume?

No. Volume is a separate metric; a keyword can be easy and have almost no searches. Look at both metrics together, along with the intent, the competition on the results page and the business value. A keyword with moderate difficulty and steady demand is often a better target than one with the lowest score.

Can KD change over time?

Yes. It is recalculated as the ranking pages and their links change. New competitors, stronger content or more links can raise it, while weaker pages dropping out can lower it. Check the score again before planning a campaign, especially if the research is several months old.

Should we show KD in client reports?

In research deliverables, yes, with the tool named. In monthly reports, rankings and traffic matter more. Explain that the score is an estimate from one tool and that different tools give different numbers. Use it to justify priorities and timelines, not as a promise of results.

Juan José Giraldo, senior white label SEO specialist

About the author

Juan José Giraldo is a senior SEO specialist with 5+ years of experience. He works on technical and local SEO for 600+ US car dealerships and supervises the SEO of 18 US e-commerce stores. He runs White Label SEO LATAM from Medellín, Colombia, and delivers white label SEO for agencies in the US, UK, Canada and Australia. Read more · LinkedIn.

Want these agency guides first? Choose White Label SEO LATAM as a preferred source on Google, and my articles are more likely to show up for you in Top Stories.

Follow on GoogleAdd as a preferred source

Sources

  1. Semrush Knowledge Base, Keyword Difficulty score
  2. Semrush Knowledge Base, How is Personal Keyword Difficulty (PKD) calculated?
  3. Ahrefs Help Center, What does KD stand for in Keywords Explorer?
  4. Ahrefs Blog, Keyword Difficulty: How to Estimate Your Chances to Rank
  5. Search Console Help, Performance report (Search results)

Ready to test a pilot client?

Book a 30-minute call. You get an honest read on fit, scope and price, with no obligation.